Child Support Takes 25% of His Paycheck — A Phoenix Dad’s Three-Year Fight to Stop Renting

Have you ever done the math on your own life and realized the numbers simply don’t leave room for a future? That was the question…

Child Support Takes 25% of His Paycheck — A Phoenix Dad's Three-Year Fight to Stop Renting
Child Support Takes 25% of His Paycheck — A Phoenix Dad's Three-Year Fight to Stop Renting

Have you ever done the math on your own life and realized the numbers simply don’t leave room for a future? That was the question sitting in the air when I met Tommy Bianchi at a diner off Interstate 10 in Phoenix on a Tuesday morning in late March 2026. He had coffee in front of him and a folder of printed documents — bank statements, a child support order, a credit card balance summary — that he’d brought without me asking.

Tommy is 46, an HVAC technician with nearly two decades in the trade. He earns a steady living. And he has been renting a two-bedroom apartment for three years, watching Phoenix home prices climb while his savings account stays essentially flat.

The Financial Wreckage of a Divorce Settlement

The divorce was finalized in early 2023. Tommy doesn’t linger on the personal details, but the financial ones he recites with the precision of someone who has run the numbers so many times they’ve become a kind of bitter mantra. He lost the house in the settlement. He put approximately $22,000 in legal fees onto two credit cards. And he now pays $1,600 per month in child support for his two kids, ages 11 and 14.

That $1,600 figure represents roughly 25% of his gross monthly income — which, by his account, runs around $6,400 before taxes. After federal and state withholding, the child support deduction, and his minimum credit card payments, Tommy told me he clears somewhere between $2,800 and $3,100 per month in take-home pay depending on overtime.

$1,600
Monthly child support payment

$22,000
Divorce legal fees on credit cards

3 yrs
Renting since the divorce

His rent is $1,450 a month for the two-bedroom — the second room is there for when his kids stay over every other weekend. That’s a cost he won’t reduce. “I’m not putting them on a pullout couch,” he told me flatly. “They already lost the family home. I’m not taking their room away too.”

The apartment eats up nearly half his take-home. The credit cards take another chunk. What remains goes toward groceries, utilities, gas for his work van, and the weekends with his kids — which, by his own admission, he handles poorly from a spending standpoint.

The Weekend Problem Nobody Talks About

Every other Friday, Tommy picks up his kids and tries to make 48 hours feel like a full life. Water parks, restaurants, video games, new sneakers. He knows the math doesn’t work. He does it anyway.

“I know I’m stress-spending. I know it. But when you only see your kids four days a month, you don’t want to spend those days saying no to everything. I’m trying to be their dad, not their warden.”
— Tommy Bianchi, HVAC technician, Phoenix, AZ

He estimates he spends between $400 and $700 on those weekends — money that in any rational budget plan would be going toward a down payment fund. Over the three years since the divorce, that’s potentially $25,000 or more that flowed toward experiences instead of equity. He knows this. Pointing it out doesn’t help, and I wasn’t there to do that.

What brought Tommy to the table with that folder of documents wasn’t guilt about weekend spending. It was a conversation with a coworker who mentioned something called the Arizona HOME Plus program — a state-run initiative that offers down payment assistance to qualifying buyers. Tommy had never heard of it. He wanted to know if it could apply to someone in his situation.

What Arizona’s Housing Assistance Programs Actually Offer

The short answer to Tommy’s question is: possibly, but not without conditions. The Arizona HOME Plus program, administered through the Arizona Department of Housing, provides eligible homebuyers with down payment assistance equal to a percentage of the loan amount — typically between 3% and 5% — offered as a forgivable second mortgage that disappears after a set period if the buyer remains in the home.

Eligibility hinges on several factors that are relevant to Tommy’s situation. Income limits apply — in Maricopa County, the income cap for many HOME Plus loan types sits around $122,100 for the program year. Tommy’s gross income of roughly $76,800 annually falls under that threshold. So far, so promising.

⚠ IMPORTANT
Down payment assistance programs like Arizona HOME Plus assess debt-to-income ratio using gross income — but child support obligations count as a monthly debt obligation in that calculation. For Tommy, $1,600/month in child support plus credit card minimums substantially affects his qualifying DTI ratio, which most lenders cap at 43-50%.

The complication comes with his debt load. Lenders qualifying buyers for assisted mortgages typically use a debt-to-income (DTI) ratio, and according to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, most conventional loans require a back-end DTI at or below 43% — though some FHA-backed loans allow up to 50% with compensating factors. Tommy’s $1,600 in child support alone represents 25% of gross income before a single debt payment is counted. Add credit card minimums, and he’s potentially looking at a DTI in the mid-to-high 30s just from existing obligations — leaving limited room for a mortgage payment.

When I explained this to Tommy, he stared at his coffee for a moment. “So the program exists, but I might not qualify because of the divorce that made me need the program in the first place,” he said. “That’s almost funny.”

The HUD Counseling Appointment That Changed His Framing

In January 2026, Tommy contacted a HUD-approved housing counselor through a nonprofit agency in the Phoenix metro area. The counseling session — which is free for eligible participants — gave him something he hadn’t expected: a concrete timeline rather than a vague sense of impossibility.

Tommy’s Housing Counselor Roadmap (January 2026)
1
Reduce credit card balances — Counselor identified two cards totaling $14,200 as priority targets to lower monthly minimums and improve DTI within 18 months.

2
Build a dedicated savings account — Even $200/month would produce approximately $3,600 over 18 months, supplemented by HOME Plus assistance if DTI qualifies.

3
Request a child support modification review — As children age and circumstances change, Arizona allows modification petitions; the counselor flagged this as worth exploring through the courts, not a guarantee.

4
Revisit HOME Plus eligibility in mid-2027 — With improved DTI, the program remains a viable option if Phoenix market conditions allow entry in the $280,000–$330,000 range for a smaller property.

Tommy described the session as the first time since the divorce that someone laid out a path that wasn’t either “you’re fine, just save more” or a shrug. “She didn’t sugarcoat it,” he told me. “She said this is hard, and here’s why, and here’s what you can actually do. That was more useful than anything I’d gotten from a bank.”

KEY TAKEAWAY
HUD-approved housing counseling is free for eligible participants and can provide personalized DTI analysis, assistance program eligibility review, and a structured savings roadmap. For people navigating post-divorce finances, it is often the starting point that banks won’t offer.

Where Tommy Stands in March 2026

When I met Tommy, he was two months into the counselor’s plan. He’d opened a dedicated savings account and was putting $150 a month into it — less than the counselor suggested, but more than zero. He’d also started paying extra on the smaller of his two credit cards, the one carrying $7,800 at 24% APR.

The weekends with his kids haven’t changed much. He’s trying. He described a recent Saturday where he took his son fishing at a city park instead of a theme park — packed sandwiches, spent almost nothing, and said his son declared it one of the best days they’d had. “I’m not sure I believe him entirely,” Tommy admitted, “but I’m going to keep trying that angle.”

“I’m not where I thought I’d be at 46. I thought I’d have a house, be coaching little league, doing the whole thing. That’s gone. What I’m trying to figure out now is what the next version of that looks like.”
— Tommy Bianchi, Phoenix, AZ

The homeownership goal is real but not imminent. If Tommy follows the counselor’s plan and the Phoenix market doesn’t spike further, the realistic window she identified was mid-to-late 2027 — roughly four and a half years after he lost his last home. That’s a long time to hold a plan together.

What struck me most, sitting across from Tommy with his folder of documents, wasn’t the bitterness he mentioned — which is present but controlled — it was the specificity of his hope. He’s not dreaming of a house in the abstract. He has a neighborhood in mind, a price range, a spare room for his kids. The plan is detailed because the loss was detailed.

Government housing assistance programs were not designed with the post-divorce middle-income earner specifically in mind. They don’t resolve the fundamental tension Tommy lives in: making enough that he doesn’t qualify for the most generous aid, but carrying enough structured debt that homeownership remains out of reach without targeted help. The programs that exist — and they do exist — require navigation, patience, and often a free conversation with a housing counselor most people don’t know to call.

Tommy paid for his coffee before I could. Said he had a job across town by nine. He tucked his folder under his arm and walked out into the Phoenix morning, headed back to work.

Related: His Wife’s Ex Stopped Paying Child Support. At 55, Carlos Mendez Is Still Feeding Four Kids

Related: A $22K Divorce Debt and $1,600 Monthly Child Support: How One Phoenix Dad Navigated the Tax Credits Nobody Told Him About

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Arizona HOME Plus program and who qualifies?

Arizona HOME Plus is a down payment assistance program administered by the Arizona Department of Housing that provides 3-5% of the loan amount as a forgivable second mortgage. In Maricopa County, income limits for many loan types sit around $122,100. Applicants must meet lender debt-to-income requirements, typically 43-50% depending on loan type.
Does child support count against your debt-to-income ratio when applying for a mortgage?

Yes. According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, child support obligations are counted as monthly debt in a lender’s back-end DTI calculation. A $1,600/month child support payment on a $6,400 gross monthly income already represents 25% DTI before any other debts are counted.
Is HUD housing counseling actually free?

HUD-approved housing counseling is free for eligible participants. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development maintains a directory of approved counseling agencies at hud.gov. Sessions typically cover budgeting, DTI analysis, program eligibility, and personalized savings planning.
Can someone modify a child support order in Arizona?

Arizona law allows either parent to petition the court for a child support modification when there has been a substantial and continuing change in circumstances — such as a significant income change. A modification is not guaranteed and requires a formal court process.
What FHA loan options exist for buyers with high debt-to-income ratios?

FHA-backed loans allow DTI ratios up to 50% in some cases when compensating factors are present. FHA loans also require a minimum 3.5% down payment for borrowers with credit scores of 580 or above, making them accessible to buyers who cannot afford a conventional 20% down payment.
366 articles

Camille Joséphine Archer

Senior Benefits & Social Programs Writer covering student loans, SNAP, housing, and VA benefits. J.D. Howard University. Former HUD Policy Analyst.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *