The morning I met Theresa Pruitt, she was sitting across from me at a corner table in a San Antonio coffee shop, a printed spreadsheet folded in her jacket pocket. She pulled it out almost immediately — columns of monthly expenses, color-coded in highlighter. That spreadsheet, she told me, was the thing that kept her from panicking.
Theresa, 39, owns Sharp Lines Barbershop on the west side of San Antonio. She responded to a call-for-sources I posted on social media in late February 2026, asking to hear from self-employed workers who were struggling with insurance costs and had looked into government assistance programs. Her reply was direct: “I’ve been dealing with this for months. I have the documents. I’ll talk.”
A Business Owner Who Did Everything Right — and Still Got Squeezed
Theresa has run Sharp Lines for six years. She employs two part-time barbers, keeps meticulous books, and has paid her taxes as a sole proprietor without fail. By most measures, she is exactly the kind of small business owner economic development offices love to highlight. Her gross annual income in 2025 was approximately $54,800.
She is single with no children. She shares a house with a roommate to keep her fixed costs down. She has, by her own description, always been cautious with money — the type to read the fine print before signing anything. None of that insulated her from what happened in January 2026.
Her private marketplace plan — a mid-tier silver plan she had carried for three years — renewed at $741 per month. The previous year’s premium had been $387. That was not a typo in her renewal notice, and it was not a billing error. When she called her insurer, a representative confirmed the increase was real and offered no meaningful explanation beyond “market adjustments.”
“I sat with that letter for probably an hour,” Theresa told me. “I kept doing the math thinking I was making a mistake. That’s almost nine thousand dollars a year just for insurance. I have an auto loan I’m already underwater on. I was helping my younger sister pay for her daughter’s daycare — about four hundred dollars a month — because she’s a single mom and I felt like I had to. When you add it all up, the numbers stopped working.”
The Medicaid Question — and Why Texas Made It Complicated
Theresa’s first instinct was to check whether she qualified for Medicaid. It seemed logical: her income had effectively shrunk due to surging expenses, she was self-employed, and she had heard vaguely that the Affordable Care Act had opened Medicaid to more people.
What she discovered was that Texas is one of ten states that, as of early 2026, has still not adopted the ACA’s Medicaid expansion under Healthcare.gov’s Medicaid guidelines. In expansion states, adults earning up to 138 percent of the federal poverty level — roughly $20,783 for a single person in 2026 — qualify for Medicaid regardless of whether they have children. In Texas, the rules are far narrower.
For a single adult without dependent children, Texas Medicaid eligibility is essentially closed at any income. The program in Texas is structured primarily around children, pregnant women, and certain individuals with disabilities. Theresa, healthy and childless, did not come close to qualifying — not because of her income, but because of her household composition.
“I actually had to have someone explain to me that I couldn’t apply,” Theresa said. “Not that I’d be denied after applying. That I couldn’t even apply. That was a strange thing to sit with. I’m running a business, I’m paying into the system — and the answer is just, no, this program isn’t for you.”
What the Marketplace Actually Offered Her
With Medicaid ruled out, Theresa turned her attention back to the ACA marketplace. She used the HealthCare.gov subsidy calculator and discovered she was in a frustrating middle zone: her income of roughly $54,800 placed her at approximately 358 percent of the federal poverty level for a single person in 2026. That made her eligible for premium tax credits — but the credits were modest enough that her net premiums still exceeded what she had paid in 2025.
After spending an evening comparing plans on HealthCare.gov, Theresa switched to a bronze plan. Her monthly premium dropped to $389 after the tax credit — nearly identical to what she had paid in 2025 on a better plan. But the tradeoff was a $7,500 annual deductible, compared to the $4,200 deductible on her old silver plan.
“I’m 39 and healthy, so I told myself the bronze plan was fine,” she said. “But I know I’m basically uninsured until I hit that deductible. One bad month and I’m in debt. That’s not coverage — that’s a gamble.”
The Costs That Came Before the Insurance Bill
Theresa’s insurance crisis did not happen in isolation. When I asked her to walk me through her full financial picture, it became clear that the premium increase was the final pressure on a budget that had been tightening for more than a year.
She is approximately $4,200 underwater on a 2020 Ford F-150 she financed in 2022 — the truck she uses to transport equipment for mobile barber events she occasionally runs for corporate clients. When used truck values dropped sharply in mid-2024, she found herself owing more than the vehicle was worth, with no clean exit from the loan.
Then there is her sister. Theresa has been contributing roughly $400 a month toward the daycare costs for her 3-year-old niece. Her sister works part-time and cannot cover the full $1,100 monthly bill at a licensed facility. Theresa never formalized the arrangement — there is no legal obligation, no repayment plan. She started paying because no one else would.
That combination — a depreciating asset she cannot offload, a family obligation she cannot bring herself to cut, and a premium increase she did not see coming — put Theresa in the position of actively researching government programs for the first time in her adult life.
Where Things Stand Now — and What She Wishes She Had Known Sooner
By the time we met in late February 2026, Theresa had made several decisions. She had switched to the bronze marketplace plan and enrolled in a Health Savings Account, contributing $200 a month to cover future out-of-pocket costs. She had not reduced her contributions to her sister’s childcare, though she said she had begun a conversation with her sister about a timeline for phasing it down.
She had also done something she had not done before: she called 211, Texas’s statewide social services helpline, to ask whether any other programs applied to her situation. She was referred to a community health clinic in San Antonio that offers sliding-scale primary care — which she is now using for routine appointments instead of routing those visits through her high-deductible plan.
“I felt embarrassed calling 211,” she told me quietly. “I own a business. I thought that line was for people who were really struggling. But I was struggling. I just didn’t want to admit it looked like that from the outside.”
The outcome is not a clean resolution. Theresa is paying less per month than she would have on the silver plan, but she has materially less coverage. She is still helping her sister. The truck loan is still underwater. What changed, she said, was that she stopped assuming the system would catch her if something went wrong — and started building her own contingency instead.
“I spent years thinking I was too middle-income to need benefits and too middle-income to really save,” she said. “I don’t think that anymore. I think that middle is where you fall the furthest if you’re not paying attention.”
When I left the coffee shop, Theresa refolded her spreadsheet and put it back in her pocket. She had a 10 a.m. appointment waiting. She said she had not missed a single day of work through any of this. That detail, more than any number she shared with me, felt like the truest picture of where she stood.
Leave a Reply