What would you do if you earned a decent income, paid your bills on time for years, and still found yourself one bad month away from losing your home — not to a dramatic collapse, but to a slow, invisible drift? That question stayed with me for weeks after I met Lucille LaRoche at a CVS pharmacy on Fredericksburg Road in San Antonio on a cold Thursday morning in January 2026.
I was picking up a prescription when I overheard a woman at the counter, calm but clearly frustrated, asking the pharmacist whether there were any manufacturer coupon programs for a blood-thinning medication. The pharmacist apologized and shook her head. The woman — Lucille — thanked her anyway, tucked the bag under her arm, and turned to leave. I introduced myself. She looked at my press badge, paused for a moment, and said, “You know what, I think I have a story you’d want to hear.”
She was right.
A Salary That Looked Fine on Paper
When I sat down with Lucille LaRoche a week later at a diner near her home in the Woodlawn Lake neighborhood of San Antonio, she was precise and measured — qualities, she told me, that come from thirty years as a legal secretary. She was 63, recently divorced after a long marriage, no children, and the sole owner of a three-bedroom house she’d refinanced twice over the years.
She earned $72,000 annually at the law firm where she worked. By most measures, she was solidly upper-middle income. “People assume that if you’re making decent money, you’ve got it handled,” Lucille told me, stirring her coffee. “But decent money in 2022 is not the same thing as decent money in 2025. And I didn’t account for that.”
In early 2022, she received a raise — roughly $9,000 more per year. She leased a newer car, added a few streaming subscriptions, started eating out more often. None of it was reckless. All of it was understandable. But when a cardiac arrhythmia landed her in the emergency room in June 2024, the cushion she thought she had evaporated almost immediately.
The ER visit, follow-up cardiology appointments, and two months of daily medication added up to roughly $11,200 in out-of-pocket costs. Her insurance covered part of it. The rest — $8,400 — went onto two credit cards. “I told myself I’d pay it down fast,” she said. “And then I looked at my property tax bill and realized I’d been making the minimum payment on that too.”
The Property Tax Problem Nobody Warned Her About
Bexar County, where San Antonio sits, has seen property valuations rise sharply since 2020. For homeowners like Lucille — people who bought years ago and have equity, but don’t have liquid cash — rising appraisals can create a slow-motion crisis. Her annual property tax bill had climbed from roughly $4,900 in 2019 to $6,800 by 2024, a nearly 39% increase over five years.
By the fall of 2025, Lucille was $4,200 behind on her Bexar County property taxes. She hadn’t defaulted, but she was approaching the threshold where penalties and interest begin compounding in ways that are very difficult to reverse. According to the Texas Comptroller’s property tax division, delinquent property taxes in Texas accrue a 6% penalty in the first month, followed by 1% per month thereafter — plus potential attorney fees if a tax lien is pursued.
What Lucille didn’t know — and what she told me she felt embarrassed not to have known — was that Texas offers several property tax relief programs for qualifying homeowners. She had never applied for any of them, partly because she assumed her income made her ineligible, and partly because no one had ever told her they existed.
What She Found — and What She Almost Missed
After our meeting at the pharmacy, Lucille went home and spent two evenings reading through the Bexar County Appraisal District website and the Texas Comptroller’s online resources. What she found changed the trajectory of her situation considerably, though not without complications.
First, she discovered she had never properly filed for the standard Texas Homestead Exemption on her primary residence. This exemption, available to all Texas homeowners who occupy their home as their primary residence, removes $100,000 from the home’s appraised value for school district tax purposes under a 2023 legislative increase. According to the Bexar County Appraisal District, the deadline to apply is April 30th of the tax year. Lucille filed in February 2026 for the 2026 tax year. She could not retroactively claim it for prior years, which she described as “the part that still stings.”
Second, she contacted the Bexar County Tax Assessor-Collector’s office to ask about a payment installment plan for her $4,200 delinquency. Under Texas Tax Code Section 33.02, property owners may enter into a written installment agreement with the tax collector to pay delinquent taxes over time. Lucille negotiated a plan to pay the balance over twelve months, approximately $350 per month, with no additional penalty accruing provided she met each payment.
Third — and this is the piece she hadn’t anticipated — she learned she was two years away from qualifying for the Texas Over-65 Homestead Exemption, which provides an additional $10,000 school district exemption and, more significantly, freezes school district taxes at the level they were in the year the exemption was first claimed. “Knowing that’s coming in two years,” she told me, “actually made me breathe differently about the whole situation.”
The Medicaid Question She Wasn’t Expecting
The prescription she’d been asking about at the pharmacy — the one that started this whole conversation — was a daily anticoagulant her cardiologist prescribed after her 2024 arrhythmia diagnosis. Without a coupon or assistance program, it ran her approximately $280 per month out of pocket after her insurance covered its portion.
When I spoke with Lucille about her health coverage, a more complicated picture emerged. She carried employer-sponsored health insurance through the law firm, but it carried a high deductible — $3,500 — that reset each January. The cardiac emergency in June 2024 had blown through that deductible and more. By the time 2025 began, she was starting from zero again.
Lucille told me she had looked into Texas Medicaid briefly but dismissed it quickly, assuming her income automatically disqualified her. That assumption was largely correct in Texas’s case — the state has not expanded Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act, meaning most adults without dependent children do not qualify for traditional Medicaid regardless of income, according to Medicaid.gov’s eligibility guidelines. At 63 and two years from Medicare eligibility, Lucille occupies what advocates often call the “coverage gap” — too much income for traditional Medicaid in non-expansion states, not yet eligible for Medicare.
What Lucille did find, through the NeedyMeds database, was a patient assistance program run by the manufacturer of her anticoagulant. After submitting income documentation and a physician’s letter, she was approved for a co-pay assistance card that capped her monthly medication cost at $35. “I almost didn’t apply because I thought, my income is too high,” she said. “But the threshold was higher than I expected. I was furious at myself for waiting so long.”
Where Lucille Stands Today — and What She’s Still Carrying
When I followed up with Lucille in late March 2026, she had made two installment payments on her property tax delinquency, totaling $700. Her homestead exemption application had been submitted and was pending confirmation from the Bexar County Appraisal District. Her medication costs had dropped from $280 to $35 per month, saving her $245 monthly — roughly $2,940 per year.
She was also, slowly, making headway on the credit card debt. “I’m not out of it,” she told me plainly. “I still have about $7,100 left on those cards. But I have a number now. Before, I just had a feeling of dread.”
The fear she carries isn’t gone. She spoke about her upcoming Medicare eligibility at 65 with a mixture of relief and anxiety — relief that it’s approaching, anxiety about the transition and what gaps might remain. She’s also watching her home’s appraisal closely, worried that even with the homestead exemption, values in her neighborhood will keep climbing.
What struck me most about Lucille was not her resourcefulness, though she had plenty of it. It was her honesty about the ways she had avoided looking at the full picture for years — the lifestyle creep she had told herself was deserved, the paperwork she had assumed would reject her before she’d even read it. She is not a person who made catastrophic choices. She is a person who got sick at the wrong time, who trusted the momentum of a decent income, and who found herself at 63 rebuilding something she hadn’t realized was eroding.
Sitting across from her in that diner booth, I kept thinking: how many other Lucilles are standing at pharmacy counters right now, asking about coupons for medications they can barely afford, not knowing that a thirty-minute search on a government website might change the math entirely. Not fix everything. But change the math.
That, she told me as we said goodbye, was enough for now.
Related: A UPS Driver’s Side Hustle Was Growing Until Tax Season Revealed the Real Cost
Leave a Reply